Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Play Stock Market Games
Fantasy Stock Picking Contest

Investments > Stock > A word on commo...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 12 Topic 70121 of 78717
Post > Topic >>

A word on commodity trading

by "Lubow" <lubow@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Apr 13, 2008 at 01:14 PM

Hello, All!

I hope nobody has gotten the impression that commodity trading is peaches
and 
cream.  It is difficult work and IMO works best when a non-pro day trades
with a 
good deal of money behind him/her.  I like day trading because small
losses do 
not mushroom into huge losses and even at $2.50 per side commission,
commissions 
can take 5% or more of your profits.

As a twenty-something my mentor in all this was Jim Kneafsey who was also
my 
thesis advisor in grad school.  Jim left academia to found Cambridge
Financial 
where his clients were at first small speculators that were referred to
him by 
Robbins Trading Co., the same company that put Larry Williams on the map. 
Later, his customers were huge pension funds within Massachusetts.  In his
first 
year trading for the MBTA Pension Fund, Jim took its $4MM stake and within
a few 
months returned $4MM in profits.  A few months later he returned $2MM
while the 
original $4MM was earning T-bill interest.

Like most CTAs (Commodity Trading Advisers) Jim positioned traded, i.e.,
kept 
the trades overnight for at least a couple of days and nothing was done at

Cambridge Financial without Jim's direct approval.  The problem with that
was 
that cancer took Jim's life almost just as quickly as one of his futures
trades. 
It was very tragic because Jim never smoked and was very athletic having
been a 
minor league ballplayer in the Cincinnati farm system.  While ill, Jim
lost 
control of everything and in the aftermath of his death it was discovered
that 
the MBTA account was around $40MM in the red (shorting can do that).

The point of this is that MBTA had a team of trustees following Jim's
trades as 
well as the auditors from Mellon Bank, the fund's custodian.  If the 
professional bean counters from two financial entities can lose track
about 
what's going on, what does that say about the rest of us?  And that's why
I 
don't like to hold a trade overnight, although I do at times (perhaps once
per 
week).

With best regards, Lubow.
 




 12 Posts in Topic:
A word on commodity trading
"Lubow" <lub  2008-04-13 13:14:35 
Re: A word on commodity trading
"BuffettHater@[EMAIL  2008-04-13 07:11:52 
Re: A word on commodity trading
"Lubow" <lub  2008-04-13 17:07:16 
Re: A word on commodity trading
"BuffettHater@[EMAIL  2008-04-13 20:07:16 
Re: A word on commodity trading
=?iso-8859-1?Q?-DirtBag=A  2008-04-14 10:08:12 
Re: A word on commodity trading
"Lubow" <lub  2008-04-14 20:16:35 
Re: A word on commodity trading
The Visitor <ksjhdsdfs  2008-04-14 20:04:43 
Re: A word on commodity trading
"BuffettHater@[EMAIL  2008-04-14 17:23:08 
Re: A word on commodity trading
"Lubow" <lub  2008-04-15 04:07:50 
On Dr. Morton Shulman
"Lubow" <lub  2008-04-15 04:16:02 
Re: On Dr. Morton Shulman
"BuffettHater@[EMAIL  2008-04-14 23:02:39 
Re: On Dr. Morton Shulman
"Lubow" <lub  2008-04-15 18:45:24 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Mon Dec 1 10:23:12 CST 2008.